NEW DELHI, INDIA — India’s rapid digital expansion has often been framed as a success story: a country sprinting into a high-tech future with cheap smartphones, mass-scale digital identity systems, and a booming online economy. But that progress keeps colliding with another truth: this government’s long, uncomfortable relationship with privacy.
The latest chapter arrived with a decision that stunned the tech industry. The Indian government quietly issued a directive ordering all smartphone manufacturers to pre-install its Sanchar Saathi “cyber safety” app on every new device sold in the country and, more concerningly, to ensure the app could not be disabled, restricted, or removed by users.
Within hours, the backlash swept across cybersecurity circles, civil society groups, and even major global manufacturers like Apple and Samsung. For a country still grappling with rising concerns around digital surveillance, this wasn’t just another clumsy policy. It felt like one more step towards a future where user choice is optional, and state access is default. Faced with the storm, the government retreated. But the bigger questions aren’t going away.
A Sudden Order, Zero Consultation — And Users Pushed Into a Corner
The now-withdrawn directive required smartphone makers to ship every new phone with the Sanchar Saathi app preloaded and permanently enabled. The deadline: 90 days. On paper, the app was framed as a tool to curb mobile fraud and verify device authenticity — a reasonable goal in a country where digital scams have become a daily nuisance.
But the way the order was issued set off alarms. There was:
- No industry consultation
- No privacy assessment
- No clarity on what data the app collects
- No option for users to disable or delete it
Tech firms pushed back instantly. Not because they oppose safety but because the directive attempted to force them into violating the privacy and platform-security rules they’re legally bound to uphold. And for many users, the issue was clear: even if the government insists the app is harmless, a mandatory system-level tool baked into every phone reads like potential surveillance infrastructure.
BJP Government Has a Pattern And People Are Not Blind to It
Public reaction wasn’t just about one app. It was the latest spark in a much bigger debate. Over the past decade, the BJP-led government has tried to mandate traceability on encrypted apps, regularly pressured platforms like X (formerly Twitter) and YouTube to remove content, expanded the scope of emergency surveillance powers, and pushed through the Digital Personal Data Protection Act with limited safeguards.
So when this app order surfaced, people’s first question wasn’t “Is it useful?”. It was “What’s the real intention?” Even those defending the app’s anti-fraud function admitted the obvious — the trust deficit exists because the government created it. When you mix mass surveillance precedents with sudden compulsory software orders, you aren’t going to get compliance. You’re going to get suspicion.
Government Backtracks — But Claims It Was All Voluntary Anyway
After days of backlash, the Ministry of Communications announced the order would be withdrawn. Their reasoning? The app is already “gaining traction” with users, so forced installation is unnecessary. It felt like a convenient face-saving line. If voluntary adoption was the intention, then why issue a mandatory pre-install directive at all?
The minister insisted that “snooping is neither possible nor will it happen.” But trust in digital governance isn’t built on assurances. It’s built on transparency, independent audits, and legally enforceable limits — none of which were offered. Digital rights groups welcomed the reversal but warned the fight isn’t over until the full legal order is published and independently verified.
Before vs After Installation: What Changes for Users?
Below is a clear, factual comparison highlighting how installing the Sanchar Saathi app affects an average user. This is the practical reality users need to understand. Even well-intentioned apps can erode privacy when the state forces them onto every device.
| Feature / Aspect | Before Installation | After App Installation |
|---|---|---|
| User Control | Full autonomy to uninstall apps | Cannot disable or uninstall |
| Location Tracking | Only when granted permission | Potentially always-on for "verification" |
| Battery Drain | Managed by OS optimization | Increased drain due to background processes |
| Data Privacy | User-approved data sharing | Direct feed to central govt servers |
| Device Identity | IMEI private to carrier/user | IMEI linked to real-time tracking DB |
Pro Tips: How to Use the App Safely?
Here are the expert-backed ways to stay protected without giving up your digital autonomy.
-
1. Don’t grant unnecessary permissions
If the app asks for access beyond what’s logically required—like media or contacts—deny it. Fraud-reporting tools shouldn't need blanket access to personal files.
-
2. Turn off background data
Prevent silent data uploads unless you're actively using the app. Go to Settings > Data Usage and restrict it.
-
3. Use it only for specific actions
If you’re reporting a scam or checking IMEI status, open the app, use it, and force close it. It doesn't need to run 24/7.
-
4. Monitor its battery and data usage
Any suspicious spikes could indicate unwanted background activity or data exfiltration.
-
5. Keep a secondary phone number
If you're privacy-conscious, avoid linking your primary number to government apps unless absolutely necessary.
-
6. Know how to uninstall it properly
On most Android devices: Settings → Apps → Sanchar Saathi → Uninstall. If your phone refuses to uninstall it, that’s a red flag. Push back on your manufacturer or carrier immediately.
-
7. Use firewall apps to restrict connections
Tools like NetGuard (no-root) can block apps from communicating with the internet except when you explicitly allow it.
-
8. Keep your phone’s OS updated
Often, the best protection against fraud is simply a secure operating system — not a new government app.
How to Protect Your Privacy Without Sanchar Saathi
If you're not comfortable installing the app at all, you can still stay safe by:
- Using your phone’s built-in IMEI tracking and "Find My Device" features.
- Avoiding unknown links and caller-ID scams.
- Blocking international or suspicious numbers manually.
- Enabling two-factor authentication on every major service.
- Using private DNS and a trusted VPN.
- Avoiding storing Aadhaar, PAN, or bank details in your gallery or WhatsApp chats.
Privacy isn’t a single app. It’s a habit.
Conclusion
For now, the Sanchar Saathi app remains voluntary. That’s good. But the real issue remains unresolved: India still lacks a transparent, rights-based digital ecosystem that people can trust. Every forced app, every sudden regulation, every vague data-sharing policy chips away at user autonomy. And unless citizens stay alert, the next directive may not be rolled back so easily.
This was a victory — but only a temporary one. In the long run, India must choose between two futures: A digital ecosystem built on consent, privacy, and open consultation, or a surveillance-first framework where the state decides what goes on your phone before you do. Right now, the trajectory is uncomfortably close to the second one.
JPhilips 
